I offered this reflection year ago, November 13, 2016, in response to the election results. It replaced a presentation I was asked to make on simplicity and ecological justice. Some of the information reflects circumstances of that particular week, such as cabinet candidates, but the points still feel relevant to me. I've only lightly edited it here for brevity and clarity.
~o~
This
was meant to be a presentation on simplicity, on contentment and joy in the
face of a consumer society fueled by injustice and greed and
sustained by a culture that values permanent dissatisfaction over
gratitude and care. It was meant to grieve how this precious earth,
this fragile whole made up of human and natural communities, has been
looted and crushed, poisoned and neglected. It was meant to celebrate
the ways, little and large, in which we could bring about healing our
own fragmented lives and communities. And it was meant to celebrate
how the earth itself, this beautiful and terrible hum of living and
dying, is worth celebrating and grieving and loving and exploring and
protecting. I was going to talk about gardening with my grandparents
and parents, and hiking with Holly. There was even a sentimental
childhood memory about buying seed potatoes and onion sets with my
father.
I
really hoped I did not have a compelling reason to put that presentation aside last Tuesday.
Although
I was not expecting a Trump victory, I was also not surprised. I have
spent a good deal of my life around people that helped carry him to
success. Although we can’t generalize to individuals, we can notice
the trends. Despite the rhetoric around economic issues, Trump’s
victory was not a blow against neoliberalism, evidenced by his
willingness to cut taxes, deregulate industry, and bust unions.
Instead, Trump’s vision appealed to those who have felt the
symptoms and impacts of neoliberalism, such as job loss, and did not
like it. Trump offered a message built around the assurance that the
spoils of neoliberalism would include the middle class, mainly white
folk who have felt their privilege threatened both by an uncertain
economic future but also by movements for equality and justice among
traditionally marginalized people who are growing in number,
visibility, and power. The economic world we have inherited and
sustained has always required the suffering and oppression of
marginalized people, especially black and brown people and women, as
well as the pillaging and destruction of the earth. So even if it
carried mainly sentimental, a-historical meanings to most followers,
the slogan “Make America Great Again” was a startling reminder of
just who has born the cost of that so-called greatness, and who will
likely bear it again. If you don’t recognize this as white
supremacy at work, then we need to have a conversation.